Unemployment rate
We've had record low unemployment, but people who work part time, are underemployed, or who have long-since give up on finding employment aren't counted as unemployed. When you add those people, the rate may double.
Weekly earnings
Per-capita income looks good for Americans, but this indicator only counts full-time workers. Our incomes drop over 30% as a nation if you count part-time (which we should if we say they are not unemployed).
Consumer Price Index
This indicator tracks prices for 80,000 goods and services, but it seems some of those goods are luxury items, and some services aren't used by the middle class. Basically, it's not just a price index for necessities, but that's what those of us who are middle class are concerned about. Rolex watches might have only increased 1%, which is great for the 1%ers, but if eggs have increased 100%, that is a bigger concern to most of us. We probably should exclude some goods and services from this index if we want to get a true sense of why people feel like they don't have enough money.
GDP
Import, exports, housing, etc. In general, people know that a healthy Gross Domestic Product is good for the economy, but if housing is expensive, it's not necessarily good for YOUR economy. I assume GDP was super-important during the post WWII manufacturing boom, but when we are in the middle of a retirement boom, not so much.
So What?
If you were frustrated with the government because of your cost of living, you more than likely voted in a way that you hoped would fix the problem. It may not get fixed with inflationary policies like tariffs, but not doing anything and just saying the economy is fine doesn't help, either.